Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The fashions of film with Sight and sound


I generally view lists boasting of 'the greatest of all time' as pure rage-bait, and usually try not to engage with them as such. Music ones are often the worst - I have never seen a list of the 100 greatest guitarists of all time that wasn't deeply embarrassing in its ignorance - but I also have little more than disdain for anybody trying to claim they know what the best movies, comics or novels are.

I do not have any issue with lists of personal favourites - we've all got those and I've churned out more than a few on this blog - but claims that somethings are the objectively greatest just annoy me on a conceptual level.

All that being said, the one list I enjoy following through the years is Sight & Sound's marvellous '100 Greatest Films of all Time'.

Partly because of the breadth of the thing. It only comes out every 10 years and the films are decided upon by a pleasantly wide range of critics and movie thinkers. They know what they are talking about and put real thought into the question of the best films ever made.  

But it's mainly because I enjoy seeing how the fashions of film change over the decades, and seeing how certain genres and directors and entire global industries go in and out of style. It's always fascinating to see what endures, and what is still thought to matter.

A general obsession with Italian post-war neo-realism comes and go, undisputed classics of the 1970s slowly fade away, and there is a pleasing awareness of representation that creates terrific new trends.

Hitchcock endures - Vertigo is a perennial at the top of the list, along with Citizen Kane and Tokyo Story, and there is always room for La Règle du jeu.

But someone like Woody Allen is a ghost of a presence these days, despite being a critical darling for much of the late 20th century (although it's impossible to get an objective read of his films when he's been revealed to be such an obviously colossal arsehole).

John Ford's support wavers, then revives; it does feel like Coppola's era has peaked, and I feel weirdly certain that Ingmar Bergman will rise again.

You won't get somebody like Tony Scott near the top of a list like this, but it does feel like there is a bigger tent for different kinds of films. I was delighted that Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles make it as the number one film of all time in the most recent list, to see it storm up the charts like that says something about the type of films that we all see as the greatest.

Few of my absolute favouite films of all time make this list - although 2001: A Space Odyssey is usually up there - but in a world of worthless cinematic lists, this one has depth. 

No comments: